Is Miguel Cabrera(I have him) for Juan Pierre and Matt Cain good deal?

not good bcuz cain duznt have the offense behind him to get a W every start and also you cant just replace a hitter that may win the triple crown. if u want this deal 2 go down hes also gonna give u another first baseman with pretty good numbers, like bily butler 4 example. and also get rid of clippard